Doomulation said:
Of course it's easy to use. Is it easy to use the ps2 controller the first time you use it? No, the point is, you get used to them
The answer you are giving me is subjective so i'm still going to say no it isn't
Doomulation said:
My point being that the gamecube pad could well work well with those had they been designed properly for the gc pad and not the ps2/xbox.
It doesn't work that way games developers please the majority first.
The gamecubes pad design isn't really a needed one its a change for the sake of change. Lets even argue that yes if made for the gamecube properly games will work on it.
But point is i will say the the other pads could handle any gamecube game simply because the accomodate for the majority of games and of course support more buttons hence a gamecube title would present the other controllers no problem however with the Gamecube controller the opposite is not true
Doomulation said:
What if they had used the same layout as the ps2? Then it would work with that pad. Again, my point being, there is nothing wrong with the controller, it is merely different.
Yes there is something wrong with it Nintendo messed around with the controllers design for apparently no reason at all.
It lacks buttons and the design doesn't accomodate most games
My arguement still would be that a standard pad should accomodate all types of games. Peripherals are something else you can add whatever fancy controller you want but the basics of a console is what sells it.
My point would be that a lot of people looked at the Cube controller and decided na that don't look like its going to be any good lets going with a PS2/XBOX.
If i was a casual gamer i would

.
You also argue that games should be made to work with it well its kind of hard to make games intuitive when they have more then 2 buttons.
Hmm Soul Calibur you had to force yourself to get used to that
Doomulation said:
Right, why don't I believe you?

Do you need an uber 1337 computer to play a game or will a moderate computer suffice? I bet sure they don't care for the design, only they use the standard for the platform they make for and blame all other designs.
Well my Pentium 500 did the job back in the day for most of my gaming needs so moderate computer should be ok
Doomulation said:
No, no, no... I have soul calibur 2 and it plays perfectly on the cube, which goes to show that the controller can handle such games. The games that work poorly on the system just did not remap the controls properly.
Oh and for that adapter part, I use a gc controller for my emulation needs (though not 2d). Although I don't have any pc games (except legacy of kain which works perfectly and wonderfully with the gc pad btw) that requires the use of a gamepad.
LOl your arguing blindly now you can remap the controls for certain games as much as you want and u won't get them to play as they should.
Well you are the minority in fact the stubborn minority.
Sales of the PS2 / Xbox should tell you something about what the mass market wants

.
I only had to ask 5 people at random and they all told me they thought the Cube controller was the worst of the bunch
Doomulation said:
That I blame sony for their fragile hardware
well it stands to reason don't abuse your consoles
Doomulation said:
Games can be made to work with it nevertheless.
Yes albeit with major control defects
Doomulation said:
Eh? I was not aware that any analog sticks can be pushed down. Actually, there's a ps2 nearby me (although I own no games for it save one... and well, I bought that a long time ago, still when I had no ps2) and I have never noticed this. One button less, what's the other differenece? Layout?
Nah, can't be arsed

Why don't you tell me? I'm eager to hear.
The other analog controllers also have smooth analog outer rims. I don't know wether Nintendo made them octagonal for asthetics but they sure is hell make my thumbs sore on Fight Night Round 2 the camera analog on
has an octagonal rim which makes moves harder to execute was one of IGNS main points on Gcube control
Doomulation said:
Well then, will you buy a ps2 despite it being so fragile? OF course you do. Then why not buy a GC because of a superb game that you will not see on another console.
Lol don't really see how that counts against the controllers
Doomulation said:
Not really. I just don't like sony. I won't get an xbox because it's so bloated, huge and bad controllers plus xbox 360 is soon coming and I'll maybe get myself one of those (plus revolution of course).
Well earlier you did say you only own Gcube so i'm guessing your opinions are biased by the fact you can't have really played with the other controllers.
Hence you argue that developers should make games work with the Cube controller
Well clever clogs answer me this
You make a good layout for Streetfighter using the cube controller and i'll never say the controller is crap again
While your at it think of a solution for that missing SSX 3 button its stopping me from doing some moves i can on the other platforms
I'm going around in circles.
The first and last and only point is that Nintendo Should release a standard pad that works with all games because the Gamecube pad is awkward.
Peripherals can be made at any point in time but the standard pad shouldn't inhibit gameplay.
It seems you are happy with these small problems with the controller thats fine but i'm not i want a controller that i know from the get go will work whatever kind of game i buy.
Last thing i want to do is avoid buying certain types of games because
Either they are not made by Nintendo hence the nagging fear the control scheme won't be right or the fact that its got less buttons and know that it just won't work.
I don't care if they release a peripheral pad in any funny layout they want as long as the Controller that i'm going to be spending the most time with works without me having to go through months of training if a 3rd party developer so decides to use more then just the B and A button.
Lastly Nintendo should cater to the consumer i don't want to cater to Nintendo.
Its like bloody Gnome all over again what with their smelly spatial browsing :|