What's new

Rape porn is dimmed legal by American Federal Judge

DuDe

Emu64 Staff
Rape porn is deemed legal by American Federal Judge

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05022/446543.stm

Anyone else thinks that it's a bit too much? I'd write my entire opinion on the matter, but as I'm not home at the moment, I can only say that sometimes the right to have a freedom of speech is being abused way too much.
 
Last edited:

Eagle

aka Alshain
Moderator
DuDe said:
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05022/446543.stm

Anyone else thinks that it's a bit too much? I'd write my entire opinion on the matter, but as I'm not home at the moment, I can only say that sometimes the right to have a freedom of speech is being abused way too much.

I do think the stuff is distastefull. However, if both parties agree before hand and the viewer knows what he or she is getting into when they watch it then under the first amendment and the internet privacy act, it is permitted. This is all provided its an act, its not real rape to my understanding of it. I have more of a problem with the fact that someone wanted to remove the basic liberties that our laws provide us. If you want freedom of speech then you have to take the good and the bad together, its a joint deal.
 

Orkin

d1R3c764 & g1|\|64 m4|<3R
IMO these videos shouldn't even exist, let alone be distributed and sold, but in the end I agree with Eagle; if it's not real rape (but consenting adults) or real murder (but simulated), then the government doesn't have the right to stop it.

It will be a sad day when the government gets to decide what gets sold based on objective qualifiers such as morality...not that I don't think morality is an important consideration. It's extremely important, but if moral standards are decided by a government that you don't agree with...
 

Zoldier01

Insanity's greater form
Its very wrong to me, but if there aint anything illigal, there isnt a way to stop it.

And obviusly, there are people who like it, else it wouldnt exist (weird enough).

~ Zoldier01
 

knowitman

New member
That is just wrong. What is this world coming to?

Who gets "turned on" by watching people get murdered?
 

Eagle

aka Alshain
Moderator
knowitman said:
That is just wrong. What is this world coming to?

Who gets "turned on" by watching people get murdered?

Not necessarily murdered, just raped. Play rape is a fetish, its another form of bondage. Basically it give some people a sense of domination over a submissive. The good thing is that most of the people with this fetish have sense enough to keep it "play rape" and not real rape. Unfortunately, some people lack such control. However, it could be said that play rape is actually a way to quell their hunger for this sort of violence and prevent them from commiting rape. Its all in how you look at it. This issue however refers not to play rape itself, but being able to purchase play rape content over the internet or on dvd.
 

ScottJC

At your service, dood!
knowitman said:
That is just wrong. What is this world coming to?

Who gets "turned on" by watching people get murdered?
Heh, there is murder in lots of things besides "rape" porn, what about horror films... even science fiction has murder in it...
 

WhiteX

New member
This sort of guy is like Larry Flint, the more we talk about him, the more he escapes thelaw. the more he gets famous, however, i see no point on banning "play rape" movies of being sold, ppl who have such fetish will look for them, ppl who doesn´t will not.
Always note that for some ppl GTA is "wrong" as "rape movies" are, so i believe that we should not be so judgemental about this, Oh! And I think it is of a bad taste too, but some ppl buy it, go figure!
 

Eagle

aka Alshain
Moderator
ScottJC said:
Heh, there is murder in lots of things besides "rape" porn, what about horror films... even science fiction has murder in it...

Exactly, some people find it exciting so they go see thrillers like Scream or Texas Chainsaw Masacre. Others find it sexually arousing.
 

vampireuk

Mr. Super Clever
knowitman said:
Who gets "turned on" by watching people get murdered?

Jesus, no honestly I saw him stood there with a giant tent pole coming out of his white robes. I mean the way he died he had a few days to get use to it, no wonder he likes it himself now.

/me puts on 27 layers of flame proof body armour
 

smegforbrain

New member
I pretty much tend to look at it this way: this is no different than getting to see "murder" in the movies, or Mena Suvari's tits in American Beauty (since she was supposed to be playing jailbait).

So... they tried to ban all child porn, even that which is made to *resemble* children... well, see Mena Suvari (and her nice tits). It just isn't that simple if it's fake, cg, or if all are consenting adults.
 

sophomore

New member
I can't say much on the specific topic, but... It's funny to me how much people complain about their rights being taken away with the idea of raising drinking ages, or prohibiting smoking in public places, or whatever. And then you get people complaining about how we have too many rights to watch simulated rape, and child porn.

I have feeling about these things too, but I just say, I wish everyone agreed with me, I wish people weren't so sick, and I wish people weren't so self-centered, but that's the society we live in, in America, we expect the right to do whatever the fuck we want and it's sad, but it's great at the same time. It's a catch-22.
 

ScottJC

At your service, dood!
Child porn? You don't have the right to watch that... whoever told you that you did should be beaten with a sharp pointy object.
 

WhiteX

New member
Yes, sophodude, you americans should do whatever the fuck you want with your lives, I don´t give a damn!
 

sophomore

New member
ScottJC said:
Child porn? You don't have the right to watch that... whoever told you that you did should be beaten with a sharp pointy object.

I didn't mean literally, I suppose you don't know what christinamodel.com is?
 

Eagle

aka Alshain
Moderator
sophomore said:
I didn't mean literally, I suppose you don't know what christinamodel.com is?

I have no idea what that is, but given the nature of this discussion, I'm reluctant to go there while at work.
 

zAlbee

Keeper of The Iron Tail
sophomore said:
I didn't mean literally, I suppose you don't know what christinamodel.com is?
.... it is a non-nude site with 18+ models. what exactly is your point? (i'm not being sarcastic).
 

EdgeBlade

Brandonn
I think feeding fantisies such as women being abused - used - controlled - and then just thrown away (killed) is just an outragously bad idea. Sex is one thing - eventualy the desire to do it for real and someone will let them. But the other stuff - viloent things - they need not be encourged. If someone surrounds themselfes with so much of something - eventually it becomes normal to them, and the desire for them to go out and do such things. And let me say, there are worse stories out their, much more distuging than slitting throts. I see women as a beautfull gift - some have lost their chame, sure - but for the most part. They aren't just some artifical disposable sex toy.
 

Top