Although many will disagree,
Final Fantasy XI is the worst game I have played this year, let me summerize the main points I have against it
1) PlayOnline, its unique system of slowness and complete rubbishness will forever plague mankind, it took me 5 hours to install and update the game, as well as the fact it is mandatory to have a credit card [except for this epassport thing]. seriously how many teens have a credit card. [target audience]
2) It puts you on a random server after you create a character, so if you wanted to play with a friend it is near impossible... well not easily, you need something called a world pass.
3) There appears to be no character customization or very little of it, you cannot change your stats once you level up, if you like everyone having the exact same build of fighter, sure thats fine but not for me.
4) The interface and controls are utterly terrible, it is exceedingly difficult to target monsters for instance, the controls are dodgy at least... forcing you to use specific keys on your keyboard... like the number pad... why? I prefer W A S and D.
5) No in-game tutorial, you basicly start having no idea what to do. Unlike everquest 2.
6) The monsters seemed like copies of each other, like for instance you get forrest rabbit and forrest hare i think, they look EXACTLY the same, same is true of other monsters.
7) In the first little area I found monsters, there were incredibly strong monsters which I could not fight and they were agressive, I almost always died very quickly, very very poor monster positioning especially for new players.
8) The battle system is very very boring, and nothing like the other FF games, its not turn based and the menus are difficult to manuver.. you could spend so much time in them you have died by the time you pick your choice.
9) Leveling is waaaaay too slow, and I heard that you must be in a party after you get to a certain level, personally I prefer to solo things so after all that I listed I just dropped this like a turd.
This game is imo the worst online game I have ever played... Its a wonder how it does so well in reviews.